10 Best Toaster Oven for Pizza 2021 | Expert Reviews

Best Toaster Oven for Pizza

With so many different kinds of countertop ovens and other cooking appliances that you can get to extend the functionality of your kitchen, going for a toaster may feel a bit outdated.

What lots of people fail to remember is the fact that these items are very versatile. So with the top rated pizza toaster oven, you can already do a lot with a classic piece of cooking equipment.

Thinking of giving these items a shot?

Our quick guide is here to help. Make sure to read all the way through and you might just find yourself decided on getting one a toaster oven for pizza nights.

Top 10 Pizza Toaster Oven 2021 – Find The Right Model:

Picture Product Name
BLACK+DECKER Pizza Toaster Oven, 8-Slice

BLACK+DECKER Pizza Toaster Oven, 8-Slice

Buy on Amazon
BREVILLE Smart Pizza Oven

BREVILLE Smart Pizza Oven

Buy on Amazon
Cuisinart Chef's Convection Toaster Pizza Ovens

Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Pizza Oven

Buy on Amazon
Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Pizza Oven

Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Pizza Oven

Buy on Amazon
Breville The Smart Pizzaiolo Pizza Oven

Breville The Smart Pizzaiolo Pizza Oven

Buy on Amazon

Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven for Pizza

Buy on Amazon
Hamilton Beach Pizza Toaster Oven

Hamilton Beach Pizza Toaster Oven

Buy on Amazon

Bialetti 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven

Buy on Amazon
Oster Extra Large Digital Toaster Oven

Oster Extra Large Digital Toaster Oven

Buy on Amazon
Hamilton Beach Extra-Large Convection Pizza Oven

Hamilton Beach Extra-Large Convection Pizza Oven

Buy on Amazon

Where to Buy Pizza Toaster Oven?

Back in the day, toaster ovens are quite prevalent that asking this question wasn’t necessary. However, nowadays, when toasters became more of a thing of the past or even staples in most households, not many know where to get one.

Luckily, the answer to where to buy a toaster oven for pizza is still relatively easy. Such items are still carried by many homeware and appliance retailers. Big box stores and appliance stores still have quite a number of options available.

For your convenience, however, you can also turn to the internet to purchase a good and reliable model.

There are lots of good places to get them from but like every other thing that you can purchase on the web, Amazon.com still proves to be the best place to source toaster ovens for pizzas.

Why? They have a wider selection than lots of other specialty retailers, for one.

You definitely have lots of options when shopping on this website so it’s a very convenient place to buy stuff. They also have great deals from time to time, so you can get more value from your money.

Buying at Amazon is also more convenient for most folks. If you’re getting other stuff as well, it’s more convenient to combine shipping or avail of promotional offers for delivery.

So if you’re thinking of getting a toaster oven, this place might be the right place for you to start your search.

However, the topic of which item to get is still more pressing than where you can buy them. With the internet being easily accessible to a wide chunk of the population, it’s extremely easy to find where you can get toaster ovens.

It’s deciding on which toaster oven you should get that will prove to be a bigger challenge.

So which one should you go for? We’ve rounded up 10 good options that you might want to check out below.

Our Picks of 10 Best Toaster Oven for Pizza Reviews:

1. BLACK+DECKER Pizza Toaster Oven, 8-Slice

BLACK+DECKER Pizza Toaster Oven,

Starting off our list is a solid alternative to a conventional kitchen oven, the Black + Decker Toaster Oven, 8-slice.

While it’s significantly smaller than most full-scale ovens, this item is already nicely sized to fit a 12” pizza or up to 8 slices of bread.

This toaster oven can also promise great flexibility. It can bake, convection cook, broil, toast, and make pizza. It also has 3 baking rack positions so you can use it to cook various dishes and ingredients.

Features:

  • Stainless steel housing
  • Pull-down door with clear viewing window
  • Convection heating technology
  • 4 functions: Bake, Broil, Toast, Keep Warm
  • 3 control knobs for cooking and temperature settings, cooking timer, and toast timer
  • 3 rack positions
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Bake/broiler pan included

2. BREVILLE Smart Pizza Oven

BREVILLE Smart Pizza Ovens

Perfect for smart kitchens is the Breville Smart Pizza Oven. Also referred to as the Compact Smart Oven, this appliance is made to impress with its smart heating technology.

What exactly is that, you ask?

Using the Element IQ® technology, this toaster oven is meant to intelligently distribute and transfer heat from its heating elements to the areas that need it. With this, you can be sure of more even cooking and better results. It also ensures a fast preheating time.

Features:

  • Brushed stainless steel body
  • 8 cooking functions: Toast, Bagel, Bake, Roast, Broil, Pizza, Cookies, and Reheat
  • Element IQ® technology
  • Non-stick coating interiors
  • Digital display
  • 1 preset knob
  • 1 setting knob
  • Start/Cancel button
  • LED indicator light
  • 1800 watts

3. Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven

Cuisinart Chef's Convection Toaster Pizza OvenIt might not say it in the name but you can also consider the Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven as a smart oven.

With its multiple sensors that are added to make using this product easier, it’s easily comparable to the ones that are marketed to be the kitchen appliances of the future.

Aside from those, its 15 cooking functions are also something worth looking into.

It can pretty much do everything you need a toaster oven to do, including dual cooking, speed convection, pizza, and reheating leftovers. With its extreme versatility, it can certainly be a great addition to any kitchen.

Features:

  • Stainless steel body
  • 15 cooking functions
  • 13” pizza capacity
  • Digital display
  • Preset buttons
  • Selector knob
  • 2-hour timer
  • Door sensor activates the oven
  • Exact Heat sensor keeps precise temperatures
  • Auto-slideout rack
  • Interior light
  • Non-stick interior
  • 2 racks, 1 pizza stone, 1 baking pan, 1 broiling pan included
  • 1800 watts

4. Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Pizza Oven

Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Toaster Ovens

For something that will blend well in a sleek, modern kitchen, the Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Toaster Pizza Oven is a solid choice.

Its black and gray coloring tends to set it apart from what lots of people think of what a toaster oven should look like so it can be a nice option for some homes.

Performance-wise, it draws homeowners in with its promise of 40% more even heat. It guarantees even heating so you can get consistent and perfect results.

With 11 cooking presets, including a dehydrator, this appliance will certainly let you do a lot more in your kitchen.

Features:

  • Stainless steel body
  • Fits a 12” pizza
  • 11 cooking modes: Bake, Pizza, Toast, Bagel, Broil, Roast, Warm, Reheat, Cookies, Defrost, and Dehydrate
  • High contrast LCD display
  • Buttons and knobs controls
  • Pizza pan, dehydrator rack, wire rack, and baking pan included
  • 1400 watts

5. Breville The Smart Pizzaiolo Pizza Oven

Breville The Smart Pizzaiolo Pizza Ovens

Also known simply as the Smart Oven, the Breville The Smart Pizzaiolo Pizza Oven is another cutting-edge kitchen appliance that you might want to check out.

It shares a few key features as the Compact Smart Oven but is bigger and has more cooking functionalities.

Capable of fitting a 13” pizza and comes with 9 cooking presets, it can certainly do a bit more than its smaller counterpart. It also has separate knobs for settings, temperature, and timer control.

Features:

  • Brushed stainless steel
  • 9 cooking modes: Toast, Bagel, Bake, Broil, Pizza, Roast, Cookies, Warm, & Reheat
  • Convection powered
  • Element IQ® technology
  • Interior light
  • Non-stick coated interiors
  • Backlit LCD screen
  • 1800 watts

6. Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven for Pizza

Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Ovens for Pizza

For busy households, the Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven will prove to be a very attractive option. As its name suggests, it’s engineered to speed up cooking by cutting down preheating time.

With its Double Infrared Heating technology, it can reach 250F to 500F up to 40% faster than other toaster ovens

It might not look like the most modern item on our list but it’s a performance-focused item. It comes with 6 cooking presets so you can count on it to help make your meal preparation simpler and faster.

Features:

  • Stainless steel body
  • Fits up to 9” pizza
  • Dedicated preset buttons
  • 6 cooking modes: Toast, Pizza, Waffle, Rolls, Hash Browns, and Reheat
  • Precise temperature control
  • Pull-down door with large see-through window
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Nonstick interior
  • 25-minute timer

7. Hamilton Beach Pizza Toaster Oven

Hamilton Beach Pizza Toaster OvensNot too keen on spending a lot on a toaster oven because you already have a full-sized oven? Then the Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven will appeal to you.

As a budget-friendly pick, it can be a more convenient appliance to use on pizza nights.

While it may be affordable, it can already do the most for pizza-loving households. Its 12” pizza capacity is a welcome feature. It’s also rather versatile with its 4 cooking modes.

Features:

  • Stainless steel exterior
  • Fits a 12” pizza
  • 4 cooking presets: Bake, Toast, Broil, and Keep Warm
  • 3 control knobs for temperature, setting, and timer control
  • 30-minute timer
  • Auto shutoff
  • Slide-out crumb tray

8. Bialetti 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven

Bialetti 6-Slice Convection Toaster Ovens

A sleek but budget-friendly option from a reputable brand is the Bialetti 6-Slice Convection Toaster Oven. Its black coloring with silver details is eye-catching but what really wins people over is its wide functionality.

While it can only handle 6-slices for toasting, it can handle up to a 12” pizza. It also has 9 pre-set cooking modes, letting you do more with a handy small appliance.

Features:

  • Stainless steel body
  • 12” pizza capacity
  • 9 cooking modes: Bake, Pizza, Cookies, Bagel, Broil, Toast, Defrost, Warm, and Reheat
  • Digital display screen
  • Digital controls
  • 2 control knobs for temperature and timer settings
  • 1800 watts

9. Oster Extra Large Digital Toaster Oven

Oster Extra Large Digital Toaster Oven

Looking for a seriously large toaster oven to help you feed an army on pizza nights more easily?

The Oster Extra Large Digital Toaster Oven would be a great choice for you. With its two baking racks that can fit a 16” pizza, it can make prepping for pizza nights a breeze.

Features:

  • Stainless steel exterior
  • Digital controls with timer display
  • Fits 2 16” pizzas
  • Convection baking technology
  • 90-minute timer
  • Auto shutoff
  • 2 cooking racks
  • 1500 watts

10. Hamilton Beach Extra-Large Convection Pizza Oven

Hamilton Beach Extra-Large Convection Pizza Ovens

If 16” pizzas are too much for you but you still want to whip up more pizzas in one go, the Hamilton Beach Extra-Large Convection Oven might do the trick.

Like the Oster item above, it has 2 baking racks. They’re just a smidge smaller as they can only fit 12” pizzas.

Features:

  • Stainless steel body
  • Fits 12” pizzas
  • 3 contoured dial knobs for Function, Temperature, and Timer control
  • 4 cooking presets: Rotisserie, Convection, Bake, and Broil
  • 2-hour timer
  • Auto shutoff

How to Cook Pizza in Toaster Oven?

How to Cook Pizza in Toaster Oven

If you’ve never owned a toaster oven before, you might find yourself slightly confused as to how to use it. Is it any different from a conventional kitchen oven? Why are there so many buttons and knobs?

While it might seem a bit intimidating at first, using a toaster oven is largely similar to using a regular oven. To help you get to know the process better, we’ll break down the steps below.

1. Read the manual.

The very first thing that you should do to know how to use a toaster oven is to read its manual. The booklet that comes with your unit will explain to you the basics of the appliance so you don’t have to operate it without any clue as to how it works.

You’ll learn a lot from these reading materials, so make sure to actually read them.

They’ll also provide important details about your unit that might not be available in other models so they’re definite must-reads if you don’t want to make a mistake in using your new cooking appliance.

2. Select the pizza setting.

Most toaster ovens have different cooking presets, so if you’re making pizza with it, it’s important to select the pizza setting. With this, you can be sure that it will get hot enough for your dough to cook nicely.

3. Preheat according to manual instructions.

Different toaster ovens have varying preheat instructions, so take note of and stick to that for the best results.

4. Pop in your pizza and start cooking.

Place your pizza on a pizza stone or high-quality baking steel then pop it into the toaster oven then start cooking. Select the necessary amount of cooking time on the timer then wait for your pizza to come out perfectly.

Buying Guide – How to Choose the Best Toaster Oven for Pizza?

With so many great options available, choosing the latest toaster oven for pizza making can be a tough decision to make. So to help you weigh your options, here are a few tips that you might find useful in your search:

1. Think about the functionalities you want your toaster oven to have.

It’s common knowledge that you should start any small appliance shopping quest by deciding on the functionalities you want to get. This applies to toaster ovens as well as they tend to come with lots of features that will allow them to give you various results.

Most oven toasters can bake, toast, and broil. However, they can also come with lots of additional features that turn them into multicookers of sorts.

Sometimes, pizza making is just an additional feature, so make sure to keep your eyes peeled for a product’s ability to make pizza.

Other models can also function as a convection oven, slow cook, proof yeasted doughs, and reheat leftovers. These make them more versatile than microwave ovens and convection ovens.

The best thing about most toaster ovens is that they’re made to be perfectly simple to use. Most will have dedicated buttons for various functionalities so you don’t have to fuss when using them.

So if you want something that can do what your oven does but is easier to work with, a toaster oven can be your best choice.

2. Take measurements in your kitchen.

Toaster ovens that can make pizzas come in various sizes, so it’s a must to take measurements before you start looking around for options.

Since these items are designed to sit on your countertop, you need to make sure that the one you’ll get will fit your kitchen.

Make sure to measure not just the width but also the depth and height of your counter. If you’re thinking of whipping up family-sized pizzas, you should be ready to give up a good chunk of counter space.

3. Consider your budget.

Like other pizza ovens, toaster ovens that can make pizza come at a very wide price range. Some are more affordable than others, as our list above will demonstrate.

By having a budget ready, not only will you be able to narrow down your options but you can also set your priorities.

Expect that the ones with more features come at higher price points. You should also take the oven’s size into consideration as the bigger the unit is, the more expensive it will most likely be.

4. Never skimp on quality.

Again, like when buying any kind of appliance, you shouldn’t ever skimp on quality. Make sure to only get a well-built product that uses high-grade materials.

Again, these items do not come cheap so you should make sure to get the value of your money.

How do you know if a product is of great quality? Look at its warranty. The longer it is, the more likely it is to be tougher and more durable.

You can also look at its reviews. Buyers will always talk about product breakdown, so keep an eye out for those kinds of feedbacks.

5. Ease of use and cleaning.

Lastly, make sure to get a toaster oven that’s easy to clean. Ovens can be a pain to maintain, so if you can find something that is designed for easy upkeep, take it into consideration.

Most of the items above have this quality by having removable crumb trays and racks as well as having non-stick interiors. These features will prove to be very handy to you once you’re using your unit heavily.

Final Verdict

Toaster ovens might not get the same love as other small countertop cooking appliances but if you want an easier way to make pizzas, it can really come in handy.

If you happen to end up with the best toaster oven for pizza, it’s highly likely that you’ll be able to use it for a wide range of other dishes as well.

So keep our tips and recommendations in mind and you might just find the right addition to your kitchen.

1 thought on “10 Best Toaster Oven for Pizza 2021 | Expert Reviews”

Leave a Comment